If you are local to Long Island or planning a trip to the North or South Forks, these established seafood markets are your best bet for fresh, day-boat Peconic Bay scallops: Southold Fish Market OpenSouthold, NY

Below is a breakdown of where you can reliably source them when they are in season. 📍 Local Fish Markets (Long Island, NY)

Agata & Valentina : This specialty Italian gourmet market has historically carried them at a premium price point (often around $78.99/lb). 💻 Online Seafood Purveyors

Located in Southampton, they frequently post real-time updates when fresh Peconic hauls arrive. 🏙️ Gourmet Grocers (New York City)

Because these highly prized, sweet bivalves have faced severe population die-offs in recent years, their availability is extremely limited and highly seasonal. The official harvest season typically opens in and runs through the winter.

Dobbs Ferry Lobster Guys : They source small batches of fresh, locally caught Peconic scallops during active season months. 💡 Important Buyer Tips