Compare and contrast different views, highlight gaps in research, and check for consistency in methodology and nomenclature.
Summarize your overall impression and state who might enjoy the item. Tips for Specific Types of Reviews
“avoid ambiguous statements like “the meaning in this paragraph is not clear”; instead query, do you mean this or that” Milne Publishing Telebe
“If you only say you liked something or didn't like something, it doesn't help the writer to know what worked for them” Pressbooks.pub
(e.g., book, restaurant, software, academic paper) are you drafting a review for? Making a Peer Review More Than a Waste of Time - OPEN SLCC Compare and contrast different views, highlight gaps in
To draft a helpful review, the approach depends on whether you are critiquing a piece of writing (like a book or essay) or sharing your experience with a product or service. General Review Structure A balanced review typically follows this flow:
When giving feedback to a peer, focus on being specific rather than general. Making a Peer Review More Than a Waste
Point out areas for improvement and offer suggestions on how they could be better.