The episode titled is actually Season 4, Episode 8 of Supernatural , while Season 5, Episode 7 is titled " The Curious Case of Dean Winchester " . [S4E8] Wishful Thinking
: The episode features a serious subplot where Sam repeatedly asks Dean if he remembers his time in Hell, which Dean denies. [S5E7] The Curious Case of Dean Winchester [S5E7] Wishful Thinking
: Sam ultimately wins the game to save Dean, who was suffering a heart attack due to old age. Other Shows with "Wishful Thinking" S5E7 The episode titled is actually Season 4, Episode
In this episode, Sam and Dean investigate a town where a wishing well at a restaurant called actually makes wishes come true, leading to chaotic results. Other Shows with "Wishful Thinking" S5E7 In this
: The brothers discover a Babylonian cursed coin—the "Seed of Chaos"—at the bottom of the well.