: Criticized by some for "reaching" on prospects.
The 2026 NFL Draft has concluded, leaving analysts to review a class defined by surprise picks at the top and a record-breaking run on pass catchers. Most experts emphasize that while "now" grades offer a snapshot of value, it often takes several seasons to truly determine a draft's success.
Analyst reviews from The Athletic and CBS Sports have identified clear trends from the weekend: :
: Praised for a "ready to win now" approach after selecting OT Spencer Fano and WRs KC Concepcion and Denzel Boston .
: While Bucky Brooks defended their strategy of rebuilding the WR room (selecting De’Zhaun Stribling ), others viewed their picks as reaches after the departures of Brandon Aiyuk and Deebo Samuel .
: Mel Kiper Jr. gave them a B+ grade , highlighting the value of Zion Young (DE) and Vega Ioane (OT).
: The selection of QB Ty Simpson has been polarizing, with some analysts calling it a major reach. Key Draft Comparisons: "Now vs. Then"
: Cited as winners for their aggressive roster building, including WR Makai Lemon . Losers/Questionable Approaches :