While contemporary critics called it "coarse" and "unfunny," modern scholars view it as a precursor to the "New Hollywood" of the 1970s. It is now praised for: Its bleak, honest look at provincial American life.
The story centers on Orville Spooner, a jealous piano teacher in the desert town of Climax, Nevada. When a famous, womanizing crooner named Dino (a parody of Dean Martin, played by Martin himself) gets stranded in town, Orville sees an opportunity to sell his songs. Fearing Dino will seduce his wife, Orville replaces her with a local prostitute, Polly the Pistol. Critique of Success Kiss Me, Stupid
Orville’s willingness to "pimp" a woman he believes is his wife highlights a moral decay fueled by ambition. While contemporary critics called it "coarse" and "unfunny,"
Martin’s self-parody was seen as too "on the nose," depicting a star who was drunken, lecherous, and cynical. When a famous, womanizing crooner named Dino (a